Film Review
Over the years, there have been direct film adaptations of the author's work, such as Joe Wright's Pride and Prejudice in 2005. And we've had movies that are loose adaptations of Austen's novels, like Bridget Jones's Diary, The Bride and Prejudice. and the hardest of them all was Pride and Prejudice and Zombies.
As for that last one, Jane Austen is surely turning in her grave, or must be going over her grave right now to beheaded by whatever studio execs have commissioned!
Renewal Of Austen Work
With Fire Island, there's another thinly veiled renewal of Austen's work, but there are times when you'll be hard-pressed to see the similarities. I don't remember Elizabeth Bennett traveling to a remote island for a week of sun, sand and I don't remember her turning off the lights in her room to have anonymous.
That's what we get in director Andrew Ahn's version of the oft-told story, this time focusing on Noah (Joel Kim Booster) and his friends trying to enjoy themselves when they visit Fire Island, the “gay Disney World”. people certainly don't walk around in corsets or button-down blouses.
Buddy Comedy
At heart, it's as much a buddy comedy about a gay group of Asian-American men as it is a love story between Noah and Will (Conrad Ricamora), a take on the venerable Mr. Darcy. It also draws attention to the prejudices of others, especially in the scenes where Noah and his friends are patronized by some of the shallow people they meet at parties because of their looks and cultural ideals.
Gay Dating Scene
The film also provides insight into the gay dating scene, where casual romance seems more important than finding a lifelong partner. That's not to say that Noah and his repressed best friend Howie are busting out their kit every ten minutes, but it's clear they both need some fun in their lives, as letting their week-long retreat to Fire Island is the way to go. away from the pressures and difficulties they face at home.
Enjoyable
As enjoyable as the film is, it would have been better if it hadn't been a Jane Austen adaptation. With scenes of characters taking MDMA and having underwear parties, it's a far cry from the author's novel, but still tries to connect with the romantic angle present in that work of fiction. Since we've seen so many iterations of Mr. Darcy over the years and the stubborn people who fall in love with him, we know exactly how the romantic subplot of this story will go.
Fire Island is an often funny film with sharp observations about race and, but when it tries to mirror Austen's novel, the plot becomes obvious and heavy. It's a shame, because the rest of the film is good, freewheeling fun with characters that don't deserve to be hampered by the conventions of past stories.
There are more interesting subplots than Noah's vacillating relationship with Will. The moments when Noah tries to help Howie lose his virginity are quite moving, for example, there are obvious thoughts about Howie's looks and his Asian identity, two factors that affect his confidence when it comes to romance.
Then there's the fact that the kids discover this will be their last time together on the island. There's a sense of poignancy as they come to terms with the passage of time and this threat to their friendship, and exploring their own feelings about that would have been more interesting than another scene of misunderstanding between Noah and Will.
Good Movie
Those criticisms aside, it's still a good movie about friendship and queer culture, and despite occasionally dabbling in serious topics like toxic masculinity and racism, it still manages to be a breezy summer movie that people of all
persuasions should enjoy.
There are plenty of comical scenes and a few one-liners, and it's great to see the main film focus on gay and Asian characters in such a fun yet respectful way. Despite the occasional groan-inducing Austen-isms and rom-com staples and what appeared online, it also had a lot of appeal with other people.
If you're looking for another film about the Asian-American experience, I heartily recommend director Ahn's Driveways, a quieter, more reflective piece. I also recommend Spa Night, which was another attempt by Ahn to explore both Asian and gay themes.
Fire Island may be poles apart from these films in terms of its sleaze and comedic appeal, but it still manages to get its point across even though the actors are dressed more skimpily than rabbits in a hatchery!
0 Comments